| 2021 |
| Sat., Oct. 30 | vs. West Central co-op | W 31-6 | 1st Round Playoffs | | Sat., Nov. 6 | @ Brown County | W 52-32 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | Sat., Nov. 13 | vs. Central A & M | L 19-21 | 3rd Round Playoffs |
| 2019 |
| Sat., Nov. 2 | vs. Tri-County [Kansas/Shiloh/Oakland | W 42-19 | 1st Round Playoffs | | Sat., Nov. 9 | vs. Greenfield/Northwestern | W 23-14 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | Sat., Nov. 16 | @ Central A-M | L 8-42 | 3rd Round Playoffs |
| 2018 |
| | vs. Catlin Salt Fork | W 31-13 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | @ Concord Triopia | L 0-42 | 2nd Round Playoffs |
| 2017 |
| | vs. Mt. Sterling | L 28-42 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 2016 |
| | vs. Hardin | L 0-8 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 2015 |
| | vs. Hardin | W 57-16 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | @ Catlin Salt Fork | W 47-14 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | @ Gibson City | W 14-13 | 3rd Round Playoffs | | | vs. LeRoy | W 42-0 | Semi-finals Playoffs | | | @ Toulon | W 35-17 | Championship Game |
| 2014 |
| | vs. Astoria | W 40-7 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | vs. Camp Point Central | L 34-41 | 2nd Round Playoffs |
| 2011 |
| | @ Oakland | W 15-13 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | vs. Pawnee | W 24-22 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | @ Tuscola | L 7-42 | 3rd Round Playoffs |
| 2010 |
| | @ Oakland | L 21-22 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 2008 |
| | Carrollton | W 21-16 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Concord Triopia | L 0-46 | 2nd Round Playoffs |
| 2007 |
| | Astoria | W 19-15 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Jacksonville | W 26-24 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | Greenfield | W 35-14 | 3rd Round Playoffs | | | Tuscola | L 6-48 | Semi-finals Playoffs |
| 2006 |
| | Mt. Olive | L 6-27 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 2002 |
| | Hardin | L 12-14 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 1999 |
| | Durand | W 42-0 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Freeport | L 6-38 | 2nd Round Playoffs |
| 1998 |
| | Mackinaw | W 40-16 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Lexington | L 13-24 | 2nd Round Playoffs |
| 1997 |
| | El Paso | W 28-0 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Monmouth | W 47-25 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | Hardin | W 28-0 | 3rd Round Playoffs | | | Galena | L 6-30 | Semi-finals Playoffs |
| 1995 |
| | Arthur | W 14-13 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Chenoa | W 30-28 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | Cerro Gordo | W 6-0 | 3rd Round Playoffs | | | Greenfield | W 26-16 | Semi-finals Playoffs | | | Carthage | L 13-45 | Championship Game |
| 1993 |
| | Martinsville | W 47-6 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Milford | W 32-0 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | Cerro Gordo | W 24-0 | 3rd Round Playoffs | | | Calhoun | L 6-7 | Semi-finals Playoffs |
| 1992 |
| | Pawnee | W 30-0 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Virden | W 26-0 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | Calhoun | L 6-10 | 3rd Round Playoffs |
| 1991 |
| | Martinsville | W 41-14 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Villa Grove | W 26-7 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | Girard | W 26-21 | 3rd Round Playoffs | | | Calhoun | W 20-7 | Semi-finals Playoffs | | | Stockton | L 6-32 | Championship Game |
| 1990 |
| | Jamaica | W 46-14 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Central Catholic | L 12-13 | 2nd Round Playoffs |
| 1989 |
| | Mt. Olive | W 24-21 (OT) | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Girard | W 25-6 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | Rossville Alvin | W 30-6 | 3rd Round Playoffs | | | Lexington | L 7-34 | Semi-finals Playoffs |
| 1988 |
| | Oakland | W 30-0 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Bement | W 14-0 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | Schlarman | W 22-8 | 3rd Round Playoffs | | | Lexington | W 6-0 | Semi-finals Playoffs | | | Hancock Central | W 15-0 | Championship Game |
| 1986 |
| | Moweaqua | W 14-6 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Macon | L 0-3 (2OT) | 2nd Round Playoffs |
| 1985 |
| | Martinsville | W 37-8 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Villa Grove | W 36-8 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | Central Catholic | W 36-3 | 3rd Round Playoffs | | | Calhoun | W 32-6 | Semi-finals Playoffs | | | Durand | W 14-6 | Championship Game |
| 1984 |
| | Jamaica | W 27-6 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Central Catholic | L 7-17 | 2nd Round Playoffs |
| 1981 |
| | Newman | W 43-7 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Gilman | L 6-8 | 2nd Round Playoffs |
| 1980 |
| | Martinsville | L 28-30 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 1978 |
| | Assumption | W 14-0 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Catlin | W 27-12 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | Routt | W 14-8 | Semi-finals Playoffs | | | Hampshire | W 42-14 | Championship Game |
| 1977 |
| | Catlin | W 20-6 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Macon | W 21-0 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | Routt | W 7-0 | Semi-finals Playoffs | | | Kingston | L 0-18 | Championship Game |
| 1976 |
| | Marshall | W 40-14 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Gillespie | L 6-19 | 2nd Round Playoffs |
|
| Arcola Playoff Totals |
| Record |
60-27-0 1986-1290 |
| Home Record | 8-4 |
| Away Record | 5-4 |
|
