| 2023 |
| Fri., Oct. 20 | vs. Boonville | W 24-0 | 1st Round Playoffs | | Fri., Oct. 27 | @ Bedford North Lawrence | W 42-6 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | Fri., Nov. 3 | @ Evansville Memorial | L 16-21 | 3rd Round Playoffs |
| 2022 |
| Fri., Oct. 21 | vs. Evansville Central | W 49-0 | 1st Round Playoffs | | Fri., Oct. 28 | @ Boonville | L 27-28 | 2nd Round Playoffs |
| 2021 |
| Fri., Oct. 22 | @ Boonville | W 41-34 | 1st Round Playoffs | | Fri., Oct. 29 | @ Northview | L 28-49 | 2nd Round Playoffs |
| 2020 |
| Fri., Oct. 23 | @ Evansville Harrison | W 56-7 | 1st Round Playoffs | | Fri., Oct. 30 | vs. Evansville Memorial | L 21-45 | 2nd Round Playoffs |
| 2019 |
| | Evansville Central | L 34-41 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 2018 |
| | Evansville Central | L 14-30 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 2017 |
| | Evansville Central | L 6-34 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 2016 |
| | Evansville Central | W 34-7 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Evansville Bosse | W 48-8 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Evansville Harrison | W 52-7 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | East Central | L 27-33 | 3rd Round Playoffs |
| 2015 |
| | Jasper | L 22-24 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Evansville Central | W 35-28 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 2014 |
| | Seymour | W 59-35 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Owen Valley | W 35-10 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Jasper | W 45-38 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | Columbus East | L 14-42 | 3rd Round Playoffs |
| 2013 |
| | Silver Creek | W 49-15 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Owen Valley | W 38-0 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Jasper | L 9-17 | 2nd Round Playoffs |
| 2012 |
| | Evansville Central | W 43-42 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Madison | W 56-7 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Jasper | W 31-30 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | Columbus East | L 21-35 | 3rd Round Playoffs |
| 2011 |
| | Boonville | W 55-21 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Evansville Central | L 35-37 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 2010 |
| | Jasper | W 47-20 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Northview | W 42-13 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Evansville Central | W 38-20 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | East Central | W 43-26 | 3rd Round Playoffs | | | Indianapolis Cathedral | L 28-56 | Semi-finals Playoffs |
| 2009 |
| | Evansville Central | W 35-7 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Seymour | W 35-0 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Jasper | W 42-6 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | East Central | W 52-28 | 3rd Round Playoffs | | | Indianapolis Cathedral | W 31-10 | Semi-finals Playoffs | | | Lowell | W 23-9 | Championship Game |
| 2008 |
| | Jasper | L 35-38 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Northview | W 40-6 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 2007 |
| | Boonville | W 47-0 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Owen Valley | W 48-13 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Jasper | W 34-8 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | Columbus East | W 61-60 | 3rd Round Playoffs | | | Indianapolis Cathedral | W 35-34 | Semi-finals Playoffs | | | Lowell | W 33-14 | Championship Game |
| 2006 |
| | Jeffersonville | W 30-0 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Evansville Harrison | W 38-14 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Bedford North Lawrence | W 40-20 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | Columbus North | L 28-35 | 3rd Round Playoffs |
| 2005 |
| | Castle | W 27-20 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Jeffersonville | W 42-14 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Evansville North | W 28-7 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | Avon | L 35-42 | 3rd Round Playoffs |
| 2004 |
| | Evansville Harrison | L 20-21 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 2003 |
| | Bedford North Lawrence | W 76-7 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Evansville North | W 23-6 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Evansville Harrison | W 56-18 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | Center Grove | L 20-31 | 3rd Round Playoffs |
| 2002 |
| | Jeffersonville | W 41-19 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Castle | W 10-7 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | New Albany | L 6-32 | 2nd Round Playoffs |
| 2001 |
| | Bedford North Lawrence | W 28-14 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Evansville Harrison | W 22-21 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Castle | W 16-14 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | Bloomington South | W 26-22 | 3rd Round Playoffs | | | Ben Davis | L 20-61 | Semi-finals Playoffs |
| 2000 |
| | Castle | L 14-34 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 1999 |
| | Castle | W 14-7 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Evansville Central | W 35-29 (OT) | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Bloomington South | L 20-35 | 2nd Round Playoffs |
| 1998 |
| | Castle | L 10-28 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 1997 |
| | Evansville Central | L 7-28 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 1996 |
| | New Albany | W 30-0 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Evansville Harrison | L 38-45 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 1995 |
| | Evansville North | L 17-21 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Castle | W 35-3 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 1994 |
| | Evansville Central | W 43-22 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Evansville Harrison | W 19-14 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Castle | L 10-23 | 2nd Round Playoffs |
| 1993 |
| | New Albany | W 38-14 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Jeffersonville | W 43-36 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Evansville Harrison | L 18-28 | 2nd Round Playoffs |
| 1992 |
| | Boonville | W 27-10 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Seymour | W 43-14 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Evansville Bosse | W 41-0 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | East Central | W 28-21 | 3rd Round Playoffs | | | Harrison West Lafayette | L 8-30 | Semi-finals Playoffs |
| 1991 |
| | Vincennes Lincoln | L 14-17 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 1990 |
| | Evansville Bosse | L 7-38 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 1989 |
| | Washington | W 10-6 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Vincennes Lincoln | W 17-0 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Mount Vernon | W 32-22 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | Mooresville | L 21-34 | 3rd Round Playoffs |
| 1988 |
| | Evansville Harrison | L 0-33 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Jennings County | W 66-6 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 1987 |
| | Bedford North Lawrence | W 35-19 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Jeffersonville | L 17-48 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 1986 |
| | Vincennes Lincoln | W 40-0 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Jasper | L 7-10 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 1985 |
| | Evansville Harrison | W 9-6 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Boonville | W 2-0 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Jasper | W 21-2 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | East Central | L 17-18 | 3rd Round Playoffs |
| 1977 |
| | Martinsville | W 22-6 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Ben Davis | W 14-13 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | Portage | L 14-33 | 3rd Round Playoffs |
| 1976 |
| | New Castle | W 10-7 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Indianapolis Cathedral | L 0-7 | Semi-finals Playoffs |
|
| Reitz Playoff Totals |
| Record |
74-39-0 3360-2291 |
| Home Record | 2-1 |
| Away Record | 3-3 |
|
